xiewg 发表于 2013-11-10 16:35

老外对LD-29的评测,很详细啊

http://lygte-info.dk/review/DriverTest%20LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20UK.html


Review/test of LD-29 2.8A 1/2 Cell Circuit board

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/DSC_3699.jpg http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/DSC_3700.jpg
http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/DSC_3701.jpg http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/DSC_3705.jpg
http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/DSC_3741.jpg


Driver is from Intl-outdoor.com, but he does not sell it anymore.

Official specifications:
[*]Suitable for 1 or 2*18650 or 26650 batteries
[*]Input voltage: 3-8.4V
[*]Current and Modes:
[*]High (2.8A) - Medium (700mA) - Low (100mA) - Strobe - SOS
[*]High (2.8A) - Medium (700mA) - Low (100mA)
[*]Current on High with 1 cell 2.5-2.6A
[*]Constant current circuit (2 cell only)
[*]Memory function
[*]This driver does not use PWM
[*]PCB Diameter: 18.5mm
[*]Contact board diameter: 20.3mm
[*]Total height: 8.9mm
[*]Gold plated contacts
[*]Low voltage protection 1 cell: at 3V the light will step down to low mode and start flashing
[*]Low voltage protection 2 cells: at 5.8V the light will step down to low mode and start flashing
[*]Reverse polarity protection
[*]Tinned leads


You can change between the set of modes by turning on the flashlight on low mode for about 3 seconds,the light will flash once, then quickly turn off the flashlight and then turn it on.



Measurements

Tested with XM-L2
Diameter 18.5 mm & 20.2 mm
Max. height: 9.3 m
Strobe 15 Hz 44% on time
Mode set 1: High, medium, low, Strobe, SOS
Mode set 2: High, medium, low
When doing a low to high test the led did not turn on.
The driver has memory, the actual mode is stored when the light is off for a short time.
A off/on will select next mode, the off has to be rather long, not to select next mode.
The driver can be used with 1 or 2 LiIon batteries in series.
The low voltage warning only works with 2 batteries.



High

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%208.4V.png

The drivers has very good regulation and good efficiency. It turns down power at 6.5 volt and battery warning comes on at 5.8 volt.
As usual efficiency and power calculations are wrong when the light is flashing.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%208.4VDriver.png

There is a maximum of 1.6 watt lost in the driver.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%208.4VLed.png

And a bit above 9 watt to the led.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%205.0V.png

With one cell, the stabilization is not that good (Led current varies between 3 and 4 volt).
The driver drops to medium mode at about 3.3 volt, this is good for keeping the led on.
There is no low voltage protection, but the driver turns off at 2.5 volt, i.e. minimum voltage for 2900/3100/3400 Panasonic cells.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%205.0VDriver.png

With one cell the loss in the driver is slightly lower.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%205.0VLed.png

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%207.2V.png
http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%203.6V.png

The output does not contain any noise.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Warning.png

The low voltage warning is slow (2 sec cycle) flashing on the led.



Medium

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%208.4V%20medium.png

Medium has the same good stabilization and does not step down, it goes directly to low battery warning at 5.8 volt.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%208.4V%20mediumDriver.png
http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%208.4V%20mediumLed.png

The led power is 2 watt.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%205.0V%20medium.png

With lower led power, the driver can sustain the medium level down to about 3.1 volt and it has very good efficiency.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%205.0V%20mediumDriver.png
http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%205.0V%20mediumLed.png

Also with one cell the led drive level is 2 watt.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%207.2V%20medium.png
http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%203.6V%20medium.png

Again a very smooth output, no traces of any pwm or driver regulation.



Low

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%208.4V%20low.png

On low the regulation is also good, the efficiency is slighty down.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%208.4V%20lowDriver.png
http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%208.4V%20lowLed.png

The led power is about 0.3 watt.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%205.0V%20low.png

With a single cell the driver works down to about 2.8 volt, before brightness drops of.

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%205.0V%20lowDriver.png
http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20HL%205.0V%20lowLed.png


http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%207.2V%20low.png
http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%203.6V%20low.png

Again a very smooth output, no traces of any pwm or driver regulation.



Strobe

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%207.2V%20strobe.png
http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%203.6V%20strobe.png

The strobe is at 15 Hz and the brightness depends on the batteries voltage (The driver cannot reach full brightness with 3.6 volt).


SOS

http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%207.2V%20sos.png
http://lygte-info.dk/pic/DriverTest/IO/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%20Circuit%20board/LD-29%202.8A%201-2%20Cell%203.6V%20sos.png

With SOS it is the same.



Conclusion

The driver is a very good stabilization (Except on high with 1 cell) and good efficiency. The mode change could be better.
There is also very little space for mounting of the two led wires.



Notes

How do I test a led driver
List of all tested drivers


lonwoo 发表于 2013-11-10 16:43

谷歌翻译的鸟文

LWPCHX2008 发表于 2013-11-10 17:14

图好大··········

kfc1039 发表于 2013-11-10 17:40

看不懂啊!

wj96202 发表于 2013-11-10 17:42

wuqiu 发表于 2013-11-10 17:42

电路做工有些粗糙,评测看起来很专业的样子

mpmpm 发表于 2013-11-10 17:46

老外使用了示波仪测试。

yls123 发表于 2013-11-10 18:13

看不懂外文。

pcsk 发表于 2013-11-11 09:57

怎么都是洋字码

本色5 发表于 2013-11-11 11:08

这是个线路板驱动的测试。

gpyhy 发表于 2013-11-11 16:52

鸟文

Since_Now 发表于 2013-11-11 20:19

99999 发表于 2013-11-14 11:49

路过路过

firebird910 发表于 2013-11-14 19:01

无奈!不懂“鹰”文,白费楼主一片苦心

RichardBillyham 发表于 2013-11-14 19:31

那么好的评测,你们通通都把它浪费了
这种先天性缺憾是你们的通病哈哈

xxc3235797 发表于 2013-11-14 19:49

嘿嘿这款电路我还是有的 呵呵确实很好 很好 很好
页: [1]
查看完整版本: 老外对LD-29的评测,很详细啊